Sep 19 Prop Picks
Tonight's Two
Our two biggest edges over the sportsbook's own price — one over, one under, from whichever market (strikeouts, outs, earned runs or hits) it shows up in. The line and the Mkt Edge are measured against a real book (pinnacle+bovada) wherever one has posted; where none has, we fall back to the nearest half-point line.
On the Record
These 15 calls are the record. Everything else on this page is projection and context — useful for finding your own angle, but not scored. Tomorrow morning each row below is graded against the box score and the running track record moves by exactly these results, win or lose. Nothing is added afterwards and nothing quietly drops out.
| Player | Market | Pick | Line | Win % |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Christian Scott | K | Over | 4.5 | 66% |
| Freddy Peralta | HITS | Over | 3.5 | 63% |
| Michael McGreevy | OUTS | Under | 17.5 | 60% |
| Tanner Bibee | HITS | Under | 5.5 | 62% |
| Noah Cameron | OUTS | Over | 15.5 | 60% |
| Grant Holmes | ER | Under | 2.5 | 65% |
| Freddy Peralta | OUTS | Over | 15.5 | 65% |
| Eury Pérez | OUTS | Over | 13.5 | 64% |
| Grant Holmes | OUTS | Over | 13.5 | 64% |
| Tarik Skubal | ER | Under | 2.5 | 67% |
| Casey Mize | ER | Under | 2.5 | 67% |
| Eury Pérez | ER | Under | 2.5 | 63% |
| Jackson Chourio | HIT | 1+ Hit | 71% | |
| Chandler Simpson | HIT | 1+ Hit | 71% | |
| Jonathan Aranda | HIT | 1+ Hit | 71% |
Strikeouts
All 30 probable starters, most projected strikeouts first — Proj K is tonight's number, Pick is the side against the nearest half-point line.
| SP | Opp | K | Pick |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tarik Skubal | SF | 7.3 | UNDER 7.5· 57% +4% |
| Cam Schlittler | ARI | 6.8 | OVER 6.5· 50% +6% |
| Reid Detmers | MIN | 6.4 | UNDER 6.5· 55% +6% |
| Joe Ryan | LAA | 6.0 | UNDER 6.5· 60% +5% |
| Christian Scott | PHI | 5.7 | OVER 4.5· 66% +7% |
| Robert Gasser | BAL | 5.5 | UNDER 5.5· 54% +5% |
| Noah Cameron | PIT | 5.5 | UNDER 5.5· 54% -1% |
| Eury Pérez | SD | 5.4 | UNDER 5.5· 55% -0% |
| José Soriano | TEX | 5.3 | UNDER 5.5· 57% |
| Jackson Jobe ⚠ | CWS | 5.2 | — |
| Sean Burke | DET | 5.2 | UNDER 5.5· 58% +6% |
| Trevor Rogers | MIL | 5.2 | UNDER 5.5· 58% +6% |
| Matthew Boyd | CIN | 4.9 | OVER 4.5· 53% +1% |
| Bryce Miller | COL | 4.9 | OVER 4.5· 51% +6% |
| Freddy Peralta | BOS | 4.8 | OVER 4.5· 51% -7% |
| Andrew Painter | NYM | 4.8 | OVER 4.5· 51% +2% |
| Brandon Pfaadt | NYY | 4.7 | UNDER 4.5· 51% -2% |
| Jacob Lopez | CLE | 4.6 | UNDER 4.5· 53% +0% |
| Tanner Bibee | ATH | 4.5 | UNDER 4.5· 54% +5% |
| Andrew Alvarez | STL | 4.4 | UNDER 4.5· 56% -6% |
| Bubba Chandler | KC | 4.3 | UNDER 4.5· 57% -0% |
| Hayden Wesneski | ATL | 4.3 | UNDER 4.5· 58% +3% |
| Nick Lodolo | CHC | 4.1 | UNDER 4.5· 61% +6% |
| Cal Quantrill | TOR | 4.1 | OVER 3.5· 50% +7% |
| Casey Mize | MIA | 4.1 | UNDER 4.5· 59% +5% |
| Michael McGreevy | WSH | 3.9 | OVER 3.5· 54% +1% |
| Grant Holmes | HOU | 3.6 | UNDER 3.5· 48% +7% |
| Yunior Marte ⚠ | LAD | 3.6 | — |
| Brayan Bello ⚠ | TB | 3.2 | — |
| Jose Quintana | SEA | 3.0 | OVER 2.5· 56% |
Hits Allowed
Hits we expect each starter to give up — Proj H is the number, the Pick is the side against the nearest half-point line.
| SP | Opp | H | Pick |
|---|---|---|---|
| Matthew Boyd | CIN | 5.39 | UNDER 5.5· 55% |
| Trevor Rogers | MIL | 5.38 | UNDER 5.5· 55% +2% |
| Brandon Pfaadt | NYY | 5.37 | UNDER 5.5· 55% +7% |
| Bryce Miller | COL | 5.36 | UNDER 5.5· 55% |
| Nick Lodolo | CHC | 5.28 | UNDER 5.5· 57% |
| Brayan Bello ⚠ | TB | 5.19 | — |
| Tarik Skubal | SF | 5.15 | OVER 4.5· 51% +7% |
| José Soriano | TEX | 5.11 | UNDER 5.5· 60% |
| Noah Cameron | PIT | 4.98 | UNDER 5.5· 62% +6% |
| Michael McGreevy | WSH | 4.97 | UNDER 5.5· 59% +7% |
| Tanner Bibee | ATH | 4.96 | UNDER 5.5· 62% +4% |
| Reid Detmers | MIN | 4.92 | OVER 4.5· 54% +7% |
| Cal Quantrill | TOR | 4.9 | UNDER 5.5· 58% +7% |
| Joe Ryan | LAA | 4.88 | OVER 4.5· 51% +7% |
| Andrew Painter | NYM | 4.88 | OVER 4.5· 54% -1% |
| Freddy Peralta | BOS | 4.82 | OVER 3.5· 63% +7% |
| Jose Quintana | SEA | 4.8 | OVER 4.5· 52% |
| Cam Schlittler | ARI | 4.75 | OVER 4.5· 48% +7% |
| Robert Gasser | BAL | 4.75 | OVER 4.5· 51% +7% |
| Hayden Wesneski | ATL | 4.75 | OVER 4.5· 51% +2% |
| Sean Burke | DET | 4.66 | UNDER 4.5· 50% |
| Bubba Chandler | KC | 4.59 | UNDER 4.5· 52% +1% |
| Jackson Jobe ⚠ | CWS | 4.55 | — |
| Jacob Lopez | CLE | 4.55 | UNDER 4.5· 52% |
| Andrew Alvarez | STL | 4.42 | UNDER 4.5· 53% +7% |
| Casey Mize | MIA | 4.41 | UNDER 4.5· 55% +1% |
| Eury Pérez | SD | 4.39 | UNDER 4.5· 55% -4% |
| Grant Holmes | HOU | 4.36 | UNDER 4.5· 56% +4% |
| Christian Scott | PHI | 4.31 | UNDER 4.5· 57% +3% |
| Yunior Marte ⚠ | LAD | 3.98 | — |
Outs Recorded
How deep into the game we expect each starter to go, in outs (3 outs = 1 inning). Blank where his outings are too up-and-down to price.
| SP | Opp | Outs | Pick |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tarik Skubal | SF | 18.6 | OVER 18.5· 51% +7% |
| Brandon Pfaadt | NYY | 17.8 | OVER 17.5· 56% +6% |
| Reid Detmers | MIN | 17.5 | OVER 17.5· 52% -7% |
| Cam Schlittler | ARI | 17.4 | OVER 17.5· 51% -1% |
| Trevor Rogers | MIL | 17.2 | UNDER 17.5· 51% +4% |
| José Soriano | TEX | 17.0 | UNDER 17.5· 54% |
| Cal Quantrill | TOR | 16.9 | UNDER 17.5· 54% -1% |
| Tanner Bibee | ATH | 16.8 | UNDER 17.5· 52% +7% |
| Matthew Boyd | CIN | 16.6 | OVER 16.5· 54% +6% |
| Michael McGreevy | WSH | 16.6 | UNDER 17.5· 60% +7% |
| Freddy Peralta | BOS | 16.5 | OVER 15.5· 49% +7% |
| Noah Cameron | PIT | 16.3 | OVER 15.5· 60% +3% |
| Hayden Wesneski | ATL | 15.9 | OVER 15.5· 44% +7% |
| Andrew Painter | NYM | 15.8 | OVER 15.5· 53% +7% |
| Bubba Chandler | KC | 15.6 | OVER 15.5· 54% +4% |
| Nick Lodolo | CHC | 15.3 | UNDER 15.5· 50% -5% |
| Christian Scott | PHI | 15.0 | UNDER 15.5· 54% -4% |
| Bryce Miller | COL | 15.0 | UNDER 15.5· 55% +3% |
| Casey Mize | MIA | 15.0 | UNDER 15.5· 53% -9% |
| Andrew Alvarez | STL | 14.9 | UNDER 15.5· 56% |
| Joe Ryan | LAA | 14.8 | UNDER 15.5· 55% |
| Jackson Jobe ⚠ | CWS | 14.7 | — |
| Jacob Lopez | CLE | 14.7 | UNDER 15.5· 56% +6% |
| Eury Pérez | SD | 14.5 | UNDER 15.5· 61% -3% |
| Grant Holmes | HOU | 14.5 | OVER 14.5· 52% |
| Robert Gasser | BAL | 14.4 | OVER 14.5· 51% |
| Sean Burke | DET | 13.7 | OVER 13.5· 54% |
| Jose Quintana | SEA | 13.2 | UNDER 13.5· 51% |
| Yunior Marte ⚠ | LAD | 12.3 | — |
| Brayan Bello ⚠ | TB | — | — |
Earned Runs
Runs we expect each starter to give up. Priced against a whole-run line (1.5 / 2.5 / 3.5). This is the noisiest of the three markets, so confidence never goes above med.
| SP | Opp | ER | Pick |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brayan Bello ⚠ | TB | 3.15 | — |
| Nick Lodolo | CHC | 2.90 | OVER 2.5· 51% |
| Bryce Miller | COL | 2.76 | UNDER 2.5· 52% |
| Matthew Boyd | CIN | 2.72 | UNDER 2.5· 53% |
| Trevor Rogers | MIL | 2.68 | UNDER 2.5· 53% -2% |
| Andrew Painter | NYM | 2.68 | UNDER 2.5· 53% -1% |
| Tanner Bibee | ATH | 2.51 | UNDER 2.5· 57% -0% |
| Freddy Peralta | BOS | 2.49 | OVER 1.5· 61% +7% |
| Brandon Pfaadt | NYY | 2.45 | UNDER 2.5· 58% +7% |
| Jose Quintana | SEA | 2.45 | UNDER 2.5· 58% |
| Robert Gasser | BAL | 2.41 | OVER 1.5· 61% +7% |
| Noah Cameron | PIT | 2.40 | UNDER 2.5· 59% +3% |
| Jacob Lopez | CLE | 2.40 | UNDER 2.5· 59% |
| Michael McGreevy | WSH | 2.37 | UNDER 2.5· 60% +7% |
| José Soriano | TEX | 2.33 | UNDER 2.5· 61% |
| Bubba Chandler | KC | 2.31 | UNDER 2.5· 61% +3% |
| Reid Detmers | MIN | 2.25 | OVER 1.5· 60% +4% |
| Sean Burke | DET | 2.25 | UNDER 2.5· 63% |
| Hayden Wesneski | ATL | 2.24 | UNDER 2.5· 63% +6% |
| Joe Ryan | LAA | 2.23 | OVER 1.5· 59% +3% |
| Eury Pérez | SD | 2.21 | UNDER 2.5· 63% +5% |
| Jackson Jobe ⚠ | CWS | 2.21 | — |
| Tarik Skubal | SF | 2.07 | OVER 1.5· 51% +7% |
| Casey Mize | MIA | 2.07 | OVER 1.5· 55% -4% |
| Christian Scott | PHI | 2.00 | OVER 1.5· 54% -3% |
| Andrew Alvarez | STL | 2.00 | UNDER 2.5· 64% +7% |
| Grant Holmes | HOU | 1.99 | UNDER 2.5· 65% +7% |
| Cal Quantrill | TOR | 1.94 | UNDER 2.5· 64% +7% |
| Yunior Marte ⚠ | LAD | 1.91 | — |
| Cam Schlittler | ARI | 1.65 | UNDER 1.5· 55% +5% |
Batter Props
63 batters across 4 posted lineups, best chances first. 1+ Hit and 1+ RBI are the odds he gets at least one tonight. The three marked PICK are our strongest 1+ Hit calls and are graded into the track record. Lineups post 3–4 hours before first pitch, so late games may still be missing.
| Batter | Team | Hit | RBI |
|---|---|---|---|
| PICK Jackson Chourio | MIL | 71% | 35% |
| PICK Chandler Simpson | TB | 71% | 27% |
| PICK Jonathan Aranda | TB | 71% | 39% |
| Kevin McGonigle | DET | 70% | 34% |
| Luis Arraez | PHI | 70% | 31% |
| Liam Hicks | TB | 70% | 38% |
| Sam Antonacci | CWS | 70% | 32% |
| Junior Caminero | TB | 69% | 39% |
| Bo Bichette | NYM | 69% | 33% |
| Andrew Vaughn | MIL | 69% | 34% |
| Mickey Gasper | BOS | 69% | 35% |
| Carson Benge | NYM | 69% | 31% |
| Jake Fraley | TB | 69% | 33% |
| Francisco Lindor | NYM | 69% | 35% |
| Juan Soto | NYM | 68% | 38% |
| Hao-Yu Lee | DET | 68% | 36% |
| Bryce Harper | PHI | 68% | 37% |
| Colt Keith | DET | 68% | 31% |
| Riley Greene | DET | 68% | 35% |
| Trea Turner | PHI | 68% | 33% |
| William Contreras | MIL | 68% | 34% |
| Roman Anthony | BOS | 68% | 32% |
| Garrett Mitchell | MIL | 67% | 33% |
| Adley Rutschman | BOS | 67% | 38% |
Milestone Watch
Players closing in on a season or career mark. Anyone playing tonight is flagged first; lineups post a few hours before first pitch.
Reached since the last card: Bryan Reynolds 150 hits · José Ramírez 1,000th career RBI · Matt Olson 150 hits · Brayan Rocchio 20 SB · Matt Olson 40 HR · Cade Cavalli 200 K · Jackson Merrill 150 hits · CJ Abrams 30 SB · Ben Rice 100 runs
| Player | Team | Milestone | Need |
|---|---|---|---|
| TONIGHT Reid Detmers | LAA | 200 K | 1 proj 6.4 K |
| TONIGHT Francisco Lindor | NYM | 300th career home run | 1 |
| TONIGHT Miguel Vargas | CWS | 100 runs | 1 |
| TONIGHT Bryce Harper | PHI | 150 hits | 2 |
| TONIGHT Caleb Durbin | BOS | 20 SB | 1 |
| TONIGHT Jackson Chourio | MIL | 20 SB | 1 |
| TONIGHT Jarren Duran | BOS | 20 SB | 1 |
| TONIGHT Jorge Mateo | ATL | 20 SB | 1 |
| TONIGHT Miguel Vargas | CWS | 20 SB | 1 |
| TONIGHT Trea Turner | PHI | 20 HR | 1 |
| TONIGHT Chase Meidroth | CWS | 150 hits | 3 |
| TONIGHT William Contreras | MIL | 150 hits | 3 |
| TONIGHT Trea Turner | PHI | 150 hits | 4 |
| TONIGHT Riley Greene | DET | 100th career home run | 3 |
| TONIGHT Junior Caminero | TB | 100 RBI | 3 |
| TONIGHT Trea Turner | PHI | 100 runs | 3 |
| TONIGHT Bryce Harper | PHI | 30 HR | 2 |
| TONIGHT Carson Benge | NYM | 20 HR | 2 |
| TONIGHT David Hamilton | MIL | 30 SB | 2 |
| TONIGHT Liam Hicks | TB | 20 HR | 2 |
| TONIGHT Sam Antonacci | CWS | 20 SB | 2 |
| TONIGHT Chandler Simpson | TB | 175 hits | 6 |
| TONIGHT Wilyer Abreu | BOS | 150 hits | 6 |
| TONIGHT Jackson Chourio | MIL | 150 hits | 7 |
| TONIGHT Jackson Jobe | DET | 100th career strikeout | 25 proj 5.2 K |
| TONIGHT Brandon Marsh | PHI | 20 HR | 3 |
| TONIGHT Cam Schlittler | NYY | 15 wins | 1 |
| TONIGHT Dillon Dingler | DET | 30 HR | 3 |
| TONIGHT Kevin McGonigle | DET | 20 HR | 3 |
| TONIGHT Kevin McGonigle | DET | 100 runs | 5 |
| TONIGHT Kyle Schwarber | PHI | 100 RBI | 5 |
| TONIGHT William Contreras | MIL | 20 HR | 3 |
| Manny Machado | SD | 400th career home run | 3 |
| Zack Wheeler | PHI | 2,000th career strikeout | 3 |
| Eugenio Suárez | CIN | 350th career home run | 1 |
| Kenley Jansen | DET | 500th career save | 3 |
| Blake Snell | LAD | 1,500th career strikeout | 8 |
| Carlos Rodón | NYY | 1,500th career strikeout | 8 |
| José Ramírez | CLE | 300th career home run | 3 |
| Jesús Luzardo | PHI | 1,000th career strikeout | 4 |
| Steven Matz | TB | 1,000th career strikeout | 4 |
| Pete Crow-Armstrong | CHC | 40-40 season | 3 SB |
| Kris Bubic | LAD | 500th career strikeout | 2 |
| Christian Walker | HOU | 200th career home run | 1 |
| Rhys Hoskins | CLE | 200th career home run | 1 |
| Willson Contreras | BOS | 200th career home run | 1 |
| Carlos Estévez | KC | 500th career strikeout | 6 |
| Carlos Rodón | NYY | 100th career win | 1 |
| JP Sears | SD | 500th career strikeout | 9 |
| Mookie Betts | LAD | 200th career stolen base | 2 |
| Gregory Soto | PIT | 500th career strikeout | 14 |
| Ian Happ | CHC | 200th career home run | 3 |
Extra Plays
The best outs and earned-run numbers on the board, same engine as the strikeout model. These sit outside the two-pick card above — they are newer markets for us, and we keep the opponent adjustment small on purpose, because this season's team splits are still mostly random.
Track Record
Every pick we post gets graded the next day against the box score — wins, losses and all — see every one →
Newest first. Past results do not predict future outcomes.
Every past card (18)
Analysis only · not gambling advice · 21+
@PropsEdgeBTN · Track record · Calculators · NFL · Blog · Learn · How it works · Archive · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · If gambling is a problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER