Props EdgeBy the numbers
Tonight's Card

Sep 19 Prop Picks

Sat · Sep 19, 2026 15-game slate · 30 starters Strikeouts · outs · earned runs · batters
Live record · since Sep 2 · 17 slates
139-86Picks graded
62%Hit rate
-7.7uUnits · $100/card
4-13Parlay record
Fair prices, not sportsbook prices. No house cut is built in, so your book will pay a little less — shop your own line before betting.
O+U

Tonight's Two

Our two biggest edges over the sportsbook's own price — one over, one under, from whichever market (strikeouts, outs, earned runs or hits) it shows up in. The line and the Mkt Edge are measured against a real book (pinnacle+bovada) wherever one has posted; where none has, we fall back to the nearest half-point line.

Tonight's Two fair odds +141 · 2.41×
Over Strikeouts Christian Scott vs Philadelphia Phillies
Our Proj5.7 Ks
PINNACLE4.5 Ks
Mkt Edge+7%
Win %66%
Fair Odds-191
Over Hits Freddy Peralta vs Boston Red Sox
Our Proj4.82 hits
PINNACLE3.5 hits
Mkt Edge+7%
Win %63%
Fair Odds-173
$100 bet · fair odds
$240.56
if both picks hit
+$140.56 profit
Fair-odds payout, not a sportsbook payout. Each pick is priced at the chance we give it (-191 Scott × -173 Peralta → +141 together, decimal 2.41). A real book takes its cut and will pay less than this.
PROPS EDGE · 2026-09-19 · our projection
15

On the Record

These 15 calls are the record. Everything else on this page is projection and context — useful for finding your own angle, but not scored. Tomorrow morning each row below is graded against the box score and the running track record moves by exactly these results, win or lose. Nothing is added afterwards and nothing quietly drops out.

PlayerSourceMarket PickLineWin %
Christian ScottTonight's TwoKOver4.566%
Freddy PeraltaTonight's TwoHITSOver3.563%
Michael McGreevyExtra playOUTSUnder17.560%
Tanner BibeeExtra playHITSUnder5.562%
Noah CameronExtra playOUTSOver15.560%
Grant HolmesExtra playERUnder2.565%
Freddy PeraltaOuts leanOUTSOver15.565%
Eury PérezOuts leanOUTSOver13.564%
Grant HolmesOuts leanOUTSOver13.564%
Tarik SkubalER leanERUnder2.567%
Casey MizeER leanERUnder2.567%
Eury PérezER leanERUnder2.563%
Jackson ChourioBatterHIT1+ Hit71%
Chandler SimpsonBatterHIT1+ Hit71%
Jonathan ArandaBatterHIT1+ Hit71%
OVERUNDERtoo closehighest-confidence pick+6% edge over the booktap a row to star it
K

Strikeouts

All 30 probable starters, most projected strikeouts first — Proj K is tonight's number, Pick is the side against the nearest half-point line.

PitcherSPOppStK%Opp K%Proj KKPickConfidence
Tarik SkubalSan Francisco GiantsSF2429.3%23.3%7.3UNDER 7.5· 57% +4%high
Cam SchlittlerArizona DiamondbacksARI3130.8%20.4%6.8OVER 6.5· 50% +6%high
Reid DetmersMinnesota TwinsMIN3027.6%22.4%6.4UNDER 6.5· 55% +6%high
Joe RyanLos Angeles AngelsLAA2523.3%25.1%6.0UNDER 6.5· 60% +5%high
Christian ScottPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI2226.6%21.8%5.7OVER 4.5· 66% +7%high
Robert GasserBaltimore OriolesBAL1822.3%25.8%5.5UNDER 5.5· 54% +5%high
Noah CameronPittsburgh PiratesPIT2821.2%24.9%5.5UNDER 5.5· 54% -1%high
Eury PérezSan Diego PadresSD2724.2%21.5%5.4UNDER 5.5· 55% -0%high
José SorianoTexas RangersTEX3021.5%22.3%5.3UNDER 5.5· 57%high
Jackson Jobe ⚠Chicago White SoxCWS722.8%23.6%5.2—low
Sean BurkeDetroit TigersDET2523.5%22.5%5.2UNDER 5.5· 58% +6%high
Trevor RogersMilwaukee BrewersMIL2823.2%21.3%5.2UNDER 5.5· 58% +6%high
Matthew BoydCincinnati RedsCIN2019.1%24.3%4.9OVER 4.5· 53% +1%high
Bryce MillerColorado RockiesCOL1923.2%21.9%4.9OVER 4.5· 51% +6%high
Freddy PeraltaBoston Red SoxBOS3021.2%21.6%4.8OVER 4.5· 51% -7%high
Andrew PainterNew York MetsNYM2120.6%22.0%4.8OVER 4.5· 51% +2%high
Brandon PfaadtNew York YankeesNYY1716.8%24.2%4.7UNDER 4.5· 51% -2%high
Jacob LopezCleveland GuardiansCLE2221.6%21.9%4.6UNDER 4.5· 53% +0%high
Tanner BibeeAthleticsATH3119.6%21.7%4.5UNDER 4.5· 54% +5%high
Andrew AlvarezSt. Louis CardinalsSTL1523.5%19.9%4.4UNDER 4.5· 56% -6%high
Bubba ChandlerKansas City RoyalsKC2820.9%20.7%4.3UNDER 4.5· 57% -0%high
Hayden WesneskiAtlanta BravesATL920.0%21.7%4.3UNDER 4.5· 58% +3%low
Nick LodoloChicago CubsCHC1919.0%21.4%4.1UNDER 4.5· 61% +6%high
Cal QuantrillToronto Blue JaysTOR1421.4%19.3%4.1OVER 3.5· 50% +7%med
Casey MizeMiami MarlinsMIA2419.3%21.5%4.1UNDER 4.5· 59% +5%high
Michael McGreevyWashington NationalsWSH2917.7%21.0%3.9OVER 3.5· 54% +1%high
Grant HolmesHouston AstrosHOU2817.7%22.0%3.6UNDER 3.5· 48% +7%high
Yunior Marte ⚠Los Angeles DodgersLAD121.1%20.7%3.6—low
Brayan Bello ⚠Tampa Bay RaysTB916.1%19.3%3.2—low
Jose QuintanaSeattle MarinersSEA914.5%23.6%3.0OVER 2.5· 56%low
H

Hits Allowed

Hits we expect each starter to give up — Proj H is the number, the Pick is the side against the nearest half-point line.

PitcherSPOppStHit%Opp Hit%Proj HHPickConfidence
Matthew BoydCincinnati RedsCIN2021.77%21.6%5.39UNDER 5.5· 55%med
Trevor RogersMilwaukee BrewersMIL2822.04%21.6%5.38UNDER 5.5· 55% +2%med
Brandon PfaadtNew York YankeesNYY1721.82%21.04%5.37UNDER 5.5· 55% +7%med
Bryce MillerColorado RockiesCOL1921.48%22.19%5.36UNDER 5.5· 55%med
Nick LodoloChicago CubsCHC1921.92%21.78%5.28UNDER 5.5· 57%med
Brayan Bello ⚠Tampa Bay RaysTB922.44%22.52%5.19—low
Tarik SkubalSan Francisco GiantsSF2421.28%21.55%5.15OVER 4.5· 51% +7%med
José SorianoTexas RangersTEX3021.35%21.31%5.11UNDER 5.5· 60%med
Noah CameronPittsburgh PiratesPIT2821.58%21.7%4.98UNDER 5.5· 62% +6%med
Michael McGreevyWashington NationalsWSH2922.11%21.56%4.97UNDER 5.5· 59% +7%med
Tanner BibeeAthleticsATH3121.63%21.61%4.96UNDER 5.5· 62% +4%med
Reid DetmersMinnesota TwinsMIN3021.08%21.39%4.92OVER 4.5· 54% +7%med
Cal QuantrillToronto Blue JaysTOR1421.53%22.45%4.9UNDER 5.5· 58% +7%med
Joe RyanLos Angeles AngelsLAA2521.84%21.24%4.88OVER 4.5· 51% +7%med
Andrew PainterNew York MetsNYM2122.22%21.68%4.88OVER 4.5· 54% -1%med
Freddy PeraltaBoston Red SoxBOS3021.86%21.72%4.82OVER 3.5· 63% +7%med
Jose QuintanaSeattle MarinersSEA921.84%21.15%4.8OVER 4.5· 52%low
Cam SchlittlerArizona DiamondbacksARI3120.54%21.16%4.75OVER 4.5· 48% +7%med
Robert GasserBaltimore OriolesBAL1821.59%21.47%4.75OVER 4.5· 51% +7%med
Hayden WesneskiAtlanta BravesATL921.54%22.17%4.75OVER 4.5· 51% +2%low
Sean BurkeDetroit TigersDET2521.53%21.61%4.66UNDER 4.5· 50%med
Bubba ChandlerKansas City RoyalsKC2821.32%21.79%4.59UNDER 4.5· 52% +1%med
Jackson Jobe ⚠Chicago White SoxCWS721.66%21.14%4.55—low
Jacob LopezCleveland GuardiansCLE2221.6%21.22%4.55UNDER 4.5· 52%med
Andrew AlvarezSt. Louis CardinalsSTL1521.17%21.54%4.42UNDER 4.5· 53% +7%med
Casey MizeMiami MarlinsMIA2421.72%22.12%4.41UNDER 4.5· 55% +1%med
Eury PérezSan Diego PadresSD2721.14%21.47%4.39UNDER 4.5· 55% -4%med
Grant HolmesHouston AstrosHOU2821.58%21.57%4.36UNDER 4.5· 56% +4%med
Christian ScottPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI2221.28%21.64%4.31UNDER 4.5· 57% +3%med
Yunior Marte ⚠Los Angeles DodgersLAD121.67%22.15%3.98—low
OUT

Outs Recorded

How deep into the game we expect each starter to go, in outs (3 outs = 1 inning). Blank where his outings are too up-and-down to price.

PitcherSPOppStIP/StProj OutsOutsPickConfidence
Tarik SkubalSan Francisco GiantsSF246.1118.6OVER 18.5· 51% +7%high
Brandon PfaadtNew York YankeesNYY176.0417.8OVER 17.5· 56% +6%high
Reid DetmersMinnesota TwinsMIN305.817.5OVER 17.5· 52% -7%high
Cam SchlittlerArizona DiamondbacksARI315.9617.4OVER 17.5· 51% -1%high
Trevor RogersMilwaukee BrewersMIL285.6317.2UNDER 17.5· 51% +4%high
José SorianoTexas RangersTEX305.6417.0UNDER 17.5· 54%high
Cal QuantrillToronto Blue JaysTOR145.3816.9UNDER 17.5· 54% -1%med
Tanner BibeeAthleticsATH315.7216.8UNDER 17.5· 52% +7%high
Matthew BoydCincinnati RedsCIN205.7416.6OVER 16.5· 54% +6%high
Michael McGreevyWashington NationalsWSH295.5216.6UNDER 17.5· 60% +7%high
Freddy PeraltaBoston Red SoxBOS305.2716.5OVER 15.5· 49% +7%high
Noah CameronPittsburgh PiratesPIT285.6916.3OVER 15.5· 60% +3%high
Hayden WesneskiAtlanta BravesATL95.4115.9OVER 15.5· 44% +7%low
Andrew PainterNew York MetsNYM215.0115.8OVER 15.5· 53% +7%high
Bubba ChandlerKansas City RoyalsKC285.0715.6OVER 15.5· 54% +4%high
Nick LodoloChicago CubsCHC195.0915.3UNDER 15.5· 50% -5%high
Christian ScottPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI224.7915.0UNDER 15.5· 54% -4%high
Bryce MillerColorado RockiesCOL195.3815.0UNDER 15.5· 55% +3%high
Casey MizeMiami MarlinsMIA245.1815.0UNDER 15.5· 53% -9%high
Andrew AlvarezSt. Louis CardinalsSTL155.0214.9UNDER 15.5· 56%high
Joe RyanLos Angeles AngelsLAA255.3514.8UNDER 15.5· 55%high
Jackson Jobe ⚠Chicago White SoxCWS74.9614.7—low
Jacob LopezCleveland GuardiansCLE224.8214.7UNDER 15.5· 56% +6%high
Eury PérezSan Diego PadresSD275.3414.5UNDER 15.5· 61% -3%high
Grant HolmesHouston AstrosHOU284.9214.5OVER 14.5· 52%high
Robert GasserBaltimore OriolesBAL185.0614.4OVER 14.5· 51%high
Sean BurkeDetroit TigersDET255.2413.7OVER 13.5· 54%high
Jose QuintanaSeattle MarinersSEA94.5613.2UNDER 13.5· 51%low
Yunior Marte ⚠Los Angeles DodgersLAD14.712.3—low
Brayan Bello ⚠Tampa Bay RaysTB94.52——low
ER

Earned Runs

Runs we expect each starter to give up. Priced against a whole-run line (1.5 / 2.5 / 3.5). This is the noisiest of the three markets, so confidence never goes above med.

PitcherSPOppStProj ERERPickConfidence
Brayan Bello ⚠Tampa Bay RaysTB93.15—low
Nick LodoloChicago CubsCHC192.90OVER 2.5· 51%med
Bryce MillerColorado RockiesCOL192.76UNDER 2.5· 52%med
Matthew BoydCincinnati RedsCIN202.72UNDER 2.5· 53%med
Trevor RogersMilwaukee BrewersMIL282.68UNDER 2.5· 53% -2%med
Andrew PainterNew York MetsNYM212.68UNDER 2.5· 53% -1%med
Tanner BibeeAthleticsATH312.51UNDER 2.5· 57% -0%med
Freddy PeraltaBoston Red SoxBOS302.49OVER 1.5· 61% +7%med
Brandon PfaadtNew York YankeesNYY172.45UNDER 2.5· 58% +7%med
Jose QuintanaSeattle MarinersSEA92.45UNDER 2.5· 58%low
Robert GasserBaltimore OriolesBAL182.41OVER 1.5· 61% +7%med
Noah CameronPittsburgh PiratesPIT282.40UNDER 2.5· 59% +3%med
Jacob LopezCleveland GuardiansCLE222.40UNDER 2.5· 59%med
Michael McGreevyWashington NationalsWSH292.37UNDER 2.5· 60% +7%med
José SorianoTexas RangersTEX302.33UNDER 2.5· 61%med
Bubba ChandlerKansas City RoyalsKC282.31UNDER 2.5· 61% +3%med
Reid DetmersMinnesota TwinsMIN302.25OVER 1.5· 60% +4%med
Sean BurkeDetroit TigersDET252.25UNDER 2.5· 63%med
Hayden WesneskiAtlanta BravesATL92.24UNDER 2.5· 63% +6%low
Joe RyanLos Angeles AngelsLAA252.23OVER 1.5· 59% +3%med
Eury PérezSan Diego PadresSD272.21UNDER 2.5· 63% +5%med
Jackson Jobe ⚠Chicago White SoxCWS72.21—low
Tarik SkubalSan Francisco GiantsSF242.07OVER 1.5· 51% +7%med
Casey MizeMiami MarlinsMIA242.07OVER 1.5· 55% -4%med
Christian ScottPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI222.00OVER 1.5· 54% -3%med
Andrew AlvarezSt. Louis CardinalsSTL152.00UNDER 2.5· 64% +7%med
Grant HolmesHouston AstrosHOU281.99UNDER 2.5· 65% +7%med
Cal QuantrillToronto Blue JaysTOR141.94UNDER 2.5· 64% +7%med
Yunior Marte ⚠Los Angeles DodgersLAD11.91—low
Cam SchlittlerArizona DiamondbacksARI311.65UNDER 1.5· 55% +5%med
BAT

Batter Props

63 batters across 4 posted lineups, best chances first. 1+ Hit and 1+ RBI are the odds he gets at least one tonight. The three marked PICK are our strongest 1+ Hit calls and are graded into the track record. Lineups post 3–4 hours before first pitch, so late games may still be missing.

BatterTeam#Opp SPvsHit%1+ HitHit1+ RBIRBI
PICK Jackson ChourioMilwaukee BrewersMIL1Trevor RogersLHP23.7%71%35%
PICK Chandler SimpsonTampa Bay RaysTB5Brayan BelloRHP25.1%71%27%
PICK Jonathan ArandaTampa Bay RaysTB2Brayan BelloRHP23.5%71%39%
Kevin McGonigleDetroit TigersDET1Sean BurkeRHP23.4%70%34%
Luis ArraezPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI4Christian ScottRHP24.8%70%31%
Liam HicksTampa Bay RaysTB4Brayan BelloRHP24.0%70%38%
Sam AntonacciChicago White SoxCWS1Jackson JobeRHP23.0%70%32%
Junior CamineroTampa Bay RaysTB3Brayan BelloRHP23.3%69%39%
Bo BichetteNew York MetsNYM3Andrew PainterRHP23.2%69%33%
Andrew VaughnMilwaukee BrewersMIL4Trevor RogersLHP23.6%69%34%
Mickey GasperBoston Red SoxBOS2Freddy PeraltaRHP22.8%69%35%
Carson BengeNew York MetsNYM4Andrew PainterRHP23.5%69%31%
Jake FraleyTampa Bay RaysTB1Brayan BelloRHP22.0%69%33%
Francisco LindorNew York MetsNYM1Andrew PainterRHP22.1%69%35%
Juan SotoNew York MetsNYM2Andrew PainterRHP22.5%68%38%
Hao-Yu LeeDetroit TigersDET2Sean BurkeRHP22.7%68%36%
Bryce HarperPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI3Christian ScottRHP23.4%68%37%
Colt KeithDetroit TigersDET3Sean BurkeRHP23.1%68%31%
Riley GreeneDetroit TigersDET4Sean BurkeRHP23.5%68%35%
Trea TurnerPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI2Christian ScottRHP22.8%68%33%
William ContrerasMilwaukee BrewersMIL3Trevor RogersLHP22.7%68%34%
Roman AnthonyBoston Red SoxBOS1Freddy PeraltaRHP21.8%68%32%
Garrett MitchellMilwaukee BrewersMIL2Trevor RogersLHP22.1%67%33%
Adley RutschmanBoston Red SoxBOS3Freddy PeraltaRHP22.2%67%38%
★

Milestone Watch

Players closing in on a season or career mark. Anyone playing tonight is flagged first; lineups post a few hours before first pitch.

Reached since the last card: Bryan Reynolds 150 hits · José Ramírez 1,000th career RBI · Matt Olson 150 hits · Brayan Rocchio 20 SB · Matt Olson 40 HR · Cade Cavalli 200 K · Jackson Merrill 150 hits · CJ Abrams 30 SB · Ben Rice 100 runs

PlayerTeamMilestoneHasNeedsNeed
TONIGHT Reid DetmersLAALAA200 K1991 proj 6.4 K
TONIGHT Francisco LindorNYMNYM300th career home run2991
TONIGHT Miguel VargasCWSCWS100 runs991
TONIGHT Bryce HarperPHIPHI150 hits1482
TONIGHT Caleb DurbinBOSBOS20 SB191
TONIGHT Jackson ChourioMILMIL20 SB191
TONIGHT Jarren DuranBOSBOS20 SB191
TONIGHT Jorge MateoATLATL20 SB191
TONIGHT Miguel VargasCWSCWS20 SB191
TONIGHT Trea TurnerPHIPHI20 HR191
TONIGHT Chase MeidrothCWSCWS150 hits1473
TONIGHT William ContrerasMILMIL150 hits1473
TONIGHT Trea TurnerPHIPHI150 hits1464
TONIGHT Riley GreeneDETDET100th career home run973
TONIGHT Junior CamineroTBTB100 RBI973
TONIGHT Trea TurnerPHIPHI100 runs973
TONIGHT Bryce HarperPHIPHI30 HR282
TONIGHT Carson BengeNYMNYM20 HR182
TONIGHT David HamiltonMILMIL30 SB282
TONIGHT Liam HicksTBTB20 HR182
TONIGHT Sam AntonacciCWSCWS20 SB182
TONIGHT Chandler SimpsonTBTB175 hits1696
TONIGHT Wilyer AbreuBOSBOS150 hits1446
TONIGHT Jackson ChourioMILMIL150 hits1437
TONIGHT Jackson JobeDETDET100th career strikeout7525 proj 5.2 K
TONIGHT Brandon MarshPHIPHI20 HR173
TONIGHT Cam SchlittlerNYYNYY15 wins141
TONIGHT Dillon DinglerDETDET30 HR273
TONIGHT Kevin McGonigleDETDET20 HR173
TONIGHT Kevin McGonigleDETDET100 runs955
TONIGHT Kyle SchwarberPHIPHI100 RBI955
TONIGHT William ContrerasMILMIL20 HR173
Manny MachadoSDSD400th career home run3973
Zack WheelerPHIPHI2,000th career strikeout1,9973
Eugenio SuárezCINCIN350th career home run3491
Kenley JansenDETDET500th career save4973
Blake SnellLADLAD1,500th career strikeout1,4928
Carlos RodónNYYNYY1,500th career strikeout1,4928
José RamírezCLECLE300th career home run2973
Jesús LuzardoPHIPHI1,000th career strikeout9964
Steven MatzTBTB1,000th career strikeout9964
Pete Crow-ArmstrongCHCCHC40-40 season44 HR / 37 SB3 SB
Kris BubicLADLAD500th career strikeout4982
Christian WalkerHOUHOU200th career home run1991
Rhys HoskinsCLECLE200th career home run1991
Willson ContrerasBOSBOS200th career home run1991
Carlos EstévezKCKC500th career strikeout4946
Carlos RodónNYYNYY100th career win991
JP SearsSDSD500th career strikeout4919
Mookie BettsLADLAD200th career stolen base1982
Gregory SotoPITPIT500th career strikeout48614
Ian HappCHCCHC200th career home run1973
+

Extra Plays

The best outs and earned-run numbers on the board, same engine as the strikeout model. These sit outside the two-pick card above — they are newer markets for us, and we keep the opponent adjustment small on purpose, because this season's team splits are still mostly random.

Freddy Peralta OVER 15.5 outs
vs Boston Red Sox · 16.5 base × 1.011 matchup → 16.5
65%fair odds -183
Eury Pérez OVER 13.5 outs
vs San Diego Padres · 15.1 base × 0.998 matchup → 14.5
64%fair odds -177
Grant Holmes OVER 13.5 outs
vs Houston Astros · 14.6 base × 1.003 matchup → 14.5
64%fair odds -177
Tarik Skubal UNDER 2.5 ER
vs San Francisco Giants · we project 2.07 earned runs
67%fair odds -199
Casey Mize UNDER 2.5 ER
vs Miami Marlins · we project 2.07 earned runs
67%fair odds -199
Eury Pérez UNDER 2.5 ER
vs San Diego Padres · we project 2.21 earned runs
63%fair odds -173
W-L

Track Record

Every pick we post gets graded the next day against the box score — wins, losses and all — see every one →

All picks 139-86 (62%)  ·  parlay 4-13  ·  -7.69 units at $100 a card

Newest first. Past results do not predict future outcomes.

Every past card (18)
Our own projections · odds shown are fair value with no house cut — not sportsbook prices
Analysis only · not gambling advice · 21+
@PropsEdgeBTN · Track record · Calculators · NFL · Blog · Learn · How it works · Archive · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · If gambling is a problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER