Props EdgeBy the numbers
Tonight's Card

Sep 18 Prop Picks

Fri · Sep 18, 2026 15-game slate · 28 starters Strikeouts · outs · earned runs · batters
Live record · since Sep 2 · 16 slates
130-81Picks graded
62%Hit rate
-9.1uUnits · $100/card
3-13Parlay record
Fair prices, not sportsbook prices. No house cut is built in, so your book will pay a little less — shop your own line before betting.
O+U

Tonight's Two

Our two biggest edges over the sportsbook's own price — one over, one under, from whichever market (strikeouts, outs, earned runs or hits) it shows up in. The line and the Mkt Edge are measured against a real book (pinnacle+bovada) wherever one has posted; where none has, we fall back to the nearest half-point line.

Tonight's Two fair odds +138 · 2.38×
Over Hits Ian Seymour vs Boston Red Sox
Our Proj4.42 hits
PINNACLE3.5 hits
Mkt Edge+6%
Win %64%
Fair Odds-181
Over Strikeouts Zac Thornton vs Philadelphia Phillies
Our Proj4.6 Ks
PINNACLE3.5 Ks
Mkt Edge+7%
Win %65%
Fair Odds-188
$100 bet · fair odds
$238.05
if both picks hit
+$138.05 profit
Fair-odds payout, not a sportsbook payout. Each pick is priced at the chance we give it (-181 Seymour × -188 Thornton → +138 together, decimal 2.38). A real book takes its cut and will pay less than this.
PROPS EDGE · 2026-09-18 · our projection
14

On the Record

These 14 calls are the record. Everything else on this page is projection and context — useful for finding your own angle, but not scored. Tomorrow morning each row below is graded against the box score and the running track record moves by exactly these results, win or lose. Nothing is added afterwards and nothing quietly drops out.

PlayerSourceMarket PickLineWin %
Ian SeymourTonight's TwoHITSOver3.564%
Zac ThorntonTonight's TwoKOver3.565%
Peter LambertExtra playOUTSUnder17.561%
Gerrit ColeExtra playOUTSOver15.561%
Ranger SuarezExtra playERUnder2.567%
Bryan WooExtra playKOver4.562%
Connor PrielippOuts leanOUTSOver14.565%
Peter LambertOuts leanOUTSOver15.563%
Ranger SuarezOuts leanOUTSOver15.559%
Randy DobnakER leanERUnder2.568%
Clay HolmesER leanERUnder2.567%
Jackson ChourioBatterHIT1+ Hit72%
Steven KwanBatterHIT1+ Hit72%
Alec BurlesonBatterHIT1+ Hit71%
OVERUNDERtoo closehighest-confidence pick+6% edge over the booktap a row to star it
K

Strikeouts

All 28 probable starters, most projected strikeouts first — Proj K is tonight's number, Pick is the side against the nearest half-point line.

PitcherSPOppStK%Opp K%Proj KKPickConfidence
Dylan CeaseTexas RangersTEX2833.0%22.4%7.9OVER 7.5· 50% +7%high
Cade CavalliSt. Louis CardinalsSTL3129.9%21.4%6.5UNDER 6.5· 54% -7%high
Ian SeymourBoston Red SoxBOS1431.4%21.5%6.2OVER 5.5· 55% +1%med
Chase BurnsChicago CubsCHC2829.4%21.2%5.9OVER 4.5· 43% +7%high
Tyler GlasnowSan Francisco GiantsSF1129.4%20.8%5.9UNDER 6.5· 48% +7%med
Bryan WooColorado RockiesCOL2824.9%21.9%5.7OVER 4.5· 62% +7%high
Connor PrielippLos Angeles AngelsLAA2023.3%24.4%5.7UNDER 5.5· 51% +5%high
Clay HolmesCincinnati RedsCIN1619.2%25.1%5.2OVER 4.5· 54% +7%high
Paul SkenesKansas City RoyalsKC3024.9%20.6%5.2UNDER 5.5· 57% +7%high
Andrew Sears ⚠Chicago White SoxCWS221.5%24.4%5.2—low
Peter LambertAtlanta BravesATL2622.0%21.7%5.2OVER 4.5· 60% +7%high
Gerrit ColeArizona DiamondbacksARI2023.4%20.3%5.2OVER 4.5· 57% +3%high
Eduardo RodriguezNew York YankeesNYY3019.8%24.0%5.2OVER 4.5· 60% +4%high
Tyler MahleHouston AstrosHOU2521.3%22.0%5.0OVER 4.5· 53% +7%high
Andrew PainterNew York MetsNYM2120.6%22.0%4.8OVER 4.5· 51%high
David Sandlin ⚠Detroit TigersDET422.3%22.5%4.8—low
Dustin May ⚠Baltimore OriolesBAL2822.3%23.7%4.6—low
Zac ThorntonPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI1320.3%22.1%4.6OVER 3.5· 65% +7%med
Nick Pivetta ⚠Miami MarlinsMIA627.8%21.5%4.6—low
Randy DobnakPittsburgh PiratesPIT1118.8%23.3%4.5OVER 3.5· 51% +7%med
Grayson RodriguezMinnesota TwinsMIN1820.3%20.8%4.4UNDER 4.5· 55% +7%high
Kyle Leahy ⚠Washington NationalsWSH2824.1%21.1%4.3—low
Kumar RockerToronto Blue JaysTOR2521.9%19.3%4.1OVER 3.5· 59% -1%high
Cesar Perdomo ⚠Los Angeles DodgersLAD219.4%20.7%4.1—low
Ranger SuarezTampa Bay RaysTB2621.4%18.7%4.0UNDER 4.5· 60% +7%high
Mason Barnett ⚠Cleveland GuardiansCLE420.1%20.9%3.8—low
Tyler PhillipsSan Diego PadresSD1820.0%21.5%3.8OVER 3.5· 52% +5%high
Daniel Espino ⚠AthleticsATH122.3%21.7%1.5—low
H

Hits Allowed

Hits we expect each starter to give up — Proj H is the number, the Pick is the side against the nearest half-point line.

PitcherSPOppStHit%Opp Hit%Proj HHPickConfidence
Bryan WooColorado RockiesCOL2821.26%22.14%5.68OVER 5.5· 50%med
Eduardo RodriguezNew York YankeesNYY3021.64%21.76%5.39UNDER 5.5· 55% +1%med
Grayson RodriguezMinnesota TwinsMIN1822.57%21.96%5.21OVER 4.5· 60% +3%med
Gerrit ColeArizona DiamondbacksARI2022.02%21.17%5.19OVER 4.5· 58% +7%med
Peter LambertAtlanta BravesATL2621.0%22.16%5.14OVER 4.5· 58% +2%med
Tyler MahleHouston AstrosHOU2522.03%21.59%5.1OVER 4.5· 58% +2%med
Cesar Perdomo ⚠Los Angeles DodgersLAD221.94%21.68%5.05—low
Connor PrielippLos Angeles AngelsLAA2022.08%21.57%5.04OVER 4.5· 55% +7%med
Clay HolmesCincinnati RedsCIN1620.97%20.84%4.96OVER 4.5· 55% +3%med
Andrew PainterNew York MetsNYM2122.57%21.64%4.95OVER 4.5· 55%med
Kumar RockerToronto Blue JaysTOR2522.14%22.48%4.95OVER 4.5· 55% -0%med
Randy DobnakPittsburgh PiratesPIT1121.87%22.15%4.94UNDER 5.5· 57% +7%med
Andrew Sears ⚠Chicago White SoxCWS221.78%21.51%4.91—low
Ranger SuarezTampa Bay RaysTB2621.71%21.83%4.83UNDER 5.5· 57% +7%med
Zac ThorntonPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI1322.08%21.64%4.81UNDER 5.5· 61% +7%med
Paul SkenesKansas City RoyalsKC3021.28%21.78%4.65UNDER 4.5· 50% +3%med
Cade CavalliSt. Louis CardinalsSTL3121.41%21.63%4.61UNDER 4.5· 51% +4%med
Dylan CeaseTexas RangersTEX2819.4%21.32%4.54OVER 3.5· 61% +7%med
David Sandlin ⚠Detroit TigersDET421.34%21.59%4.5—low
Chase BurnsChicago CubsCHC2820.9%21.65%4.49OVER 2.5· 52% +7%med
Tyler GlasnowSan Francisco GiantsSF1120.69%22.26%4.49UNDER 4.5· 53%med
Ian SeymourBoston Red SoxBOS1421.98%21.72%4.42OVER 3.5· 64% +6%med
Mason Barnett ⚠Cleveland GuardiansCLE422.02%21.61%4.3—low
Dustin May ⚠Baltimore OriolesBAL2822.02%21.15%4.21—low
Kyle Leahy ⚠Washington NationalsWSH2822.64%21.56%4.09—low
Tyler PhillipsSan Diego PadresSD1821.78%21.46%3.92UNDER 4.5· 53% +7%med
Nick Pivetta ⚠Miami MarlinsMIA621.47%22.11%3.43—low
Daniel Espino ⚠AthleticsATH121.66%21.62%1.48—low
OUT

Outs Recorded

How deep into the game we expect each starter to go, in outs (3 outs = 1 inning). Blank where his outings are too up-and-down to price.

PitcherSPOppStIP/StProj OutsOutsPickConfidence
Eduardo RodriguezNew York YankeesNYY305.9417.5OVER 17.5· 52% +4%high
Bryan WooColorado RockiesCOL285.817.0UNDER 17.5· 49% +7%high
Dylan CeaseTexas RangersTEX285.9416.9UNDER 17.5· 48% +7%high
Tyler MahleHouston AstrosHOU255.5216.8UNDER 17.5· 57% +7%high
Clay HolmesCincinnati RedsCIN165.7316.7OVER 15.5· 57% +7%high
Gerrit ColeArizona DiamondbacksARI205.7616.7OVER 15.5· 61% +7%high
Zac ThorntonPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI135.6416.7OVER 16.5· 55% +5%med
Peter LambertAtlanta BravesATL265.616.3UNDER 17.5· 61% +7%high
David Sandlin ⚠Detroit TigersDET45.4216.3—low
Ranger SuarezTampa Bay RaysTB265.316.3UNDER 17.5· 56% +7%high
Paul SkenesKansas City RoyalsKC305.416.1UNDER 17.5· 59% +7%high
Cesar Perdomo ⚠Los Angeles DodgersLAD25.3516.1—low
Andrew PainterNew York MetsNYM215.0115.9UNDER 16.5· 55%high
Grayson RodriguezMinnesota TwinsMIN184.8315.7UNDER 16.5· 56% +7%high
Cade CavalliSt. Louis CardinalsSTL315.3115.6UNDER 17.5· 54% +7%high
Tyler GlasnowSan Francisco GiantsSF115.6115.6OVER 15.5· 53%med
Randy DobnakPittsburgh PiratesPIT115.4315.6OVER 15.5· 51% +7%med
Connor PrielippLos Angeles AngelsLAA205.2115.4OVER 15.5· 51%high
Ian SeymourBoston Red SoxBOS144.7914.7UNDER 15.5· 56% -0%med
Andrew Sears ⚠Chicago White SoxCWS25.014.7—low
Kumar RockerToronto Blue JaysTOR254.8414.7OVER 14.5· 54% -7%high
Chase BurnsChicago CubsCHC285.414.6OVER 14.5· 54%high
Tyler PhillipsSan Diego PadresSD184.5713.8UNDER 14.5· 55%high
Dustin May ⚠Baltimore OriolesBAL284.94——low
Nick Pivetta ⚠Miami MarlinsMIA64.17——low
Kyle Leahy ⚠Washington NationalsWSH284.82——low
Mason Barnett ⚠Cleveland GuardiansCLE44.0——low
Daniel Espino ⚠AthleticsATH12.0——low
ER

Earned Runs

Runs we expect each starter to give up. Priced against a whole-run line (1.5 / 2.5 / 3.5). This is the noisiest of the three markets, so confidence never goes above med.

PitcherSPOppStProj ERERPickConfidence
Grayson RodriguezMinnesota TwinsMIN183.06OVER 2.5· 52% +7%med
Connor PrielippLos Angeles AngelsLAA202.90OVER 2.5· 49% +7%med
Bryan WooColorado RockiesCOL282.83UNDER 2.5· 51%med
Andrew PainterNew York MetsNYM212.76UNDER 2.5· 52%med
Mason Barnett ⚠Cleveland GuardiansCLE42.63—low
Tyler MahleHouston AstrosHOU252.43UNDER 2.5· 59% +4%med
Kumar RockerToronto Blue JaysTOR252.40UNDER 2.5· 60% +3%med
Cesar Perdomo ⚠Los Angeles DodgersLAD22.39—low
Peter LambertAtlanta BravesATL262.37UNDER 2.5· 60% +7%med
Andrew Sears ⚠Chicago White SoxCWS22.36—low
Gerrit ColeArizona DiamondbacksARI202.32OVER 1.5· 60% +1%med
Ian SeymourBoston Red SoxBOS142.28OVER 1.5· 58% +7%med
David Sandlin ⚠Detroit TigersDET42.24—low
Paul SkenesKansas City RoyalsKC302.21OVER 1.5· 58% -1%med
Dustin May ⚠Baltimore OriolesBAL282.20—low
Tyler GlasnowSan Francisco GiantsSF112.14UNDER 2.5· 65%med
Zac ThorntonPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI132.14UNDER 2.5· 65% +7%med
Clay HolmesCincinnati RedsCIN162.04UNDER 2.5· 63% +7%med
Ranger SuarezTampa Bay RaysTB262.02UNDER 2.5· 67% +7%med
Randy DobnakPittsburgh PiratesPIT112.01UNDER 2.5· 58% +7%med
Tyler PhillipsSan Diego PadresSD181.96UNDER 2.5· 64% +7%med
Eduardo RodriguezNew York YankeesNYY301.95UNDER 2.5· 55% +7%med
Chase BurnsChicago CubsCHC281.86OVER 0.5· 69% +7%med
Cade CavalliSt. Louis CardinalsSTL311.83UNDER 1.5· 51% +7%med
Dylan CeaseTexas RangersTEX281.73UNDER 1.5· 53% +7%med
Kyle Leahy ⚠Washington NationalsWSH281.68—low
Nick Pivetta ⚠Miami MarlinsMIA61.61—low
Daniel Espino ⚠AthleticsATH10.67—low
BAT

Batter Props

144 batters across 11 posted lineups, best chances first. 1+ Hit and 1+ RBI are the odds he gets at least one tonight. The three marked PICK are our strongest 1+ Hit calls and are graded into the track record. Lineups post 3–4 hours before first pitch, so late games may still be missing.

BatterTeam#Opp SPvsHit%1+ HitHit1+ RBIRBI
PICK Jackson ChourioMilwaukee BrewersMIL1Cade PovichRHP23.8%72%38%
PICK Steven KwanCleveland GuardiansCLE1Mason BarnettRHP23.9%72%27%
PICK Alec BurlesonSt. Louis CardinalsSTL3Cade CavalliRHP25.2%71%40%
Nick GonzalesPittsburgh PiratesPIT5Randy DobnakRHP25.7%71%33%
Jake McCarthyColorado RockiesCOL1Bryan WooRHP24.2%71%37%
Drake BaldwinAtlanta BravesATL1Peter LambertRHP24.3%71%40%
Randal GrichukChicago White SoxCWS3Andrew SearsLHP24.6%71%35%
Yandy DíazTampa Bay RaysTB1Ranger SuarezLHP23.4%70%38%
Luis ArraezPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI4Zac ThorntonLHP24.5%70%33%
Brice TurangMilwaukee BrewersMIL2Cade PovichRHP23.3%70%40%
TJ RumfieldColorado RockiesCOL3Bryan WooRHP24.6%70%34%
Brandon LowePittsburgh PiratesPIT2Randy DobnakRHP23.5%70%41%
Michael Harris IIAtlanta BravesATL4Peter LambertRHP25.0%70%38%
Pete Crow-ArmstrongChicago CubsCHC1Chase BurnsRHP23.3%69%40%
Henry BolteAthleticsATH1Daniel EspinoRHP22.9%69%29%
William ContrerasMilwaukee BrewersMIL3Cade PovichRHP23.2%69%38%
Bobby Witt Jr.Kansas City RoyalsKC2Paul SkenesRHP23.4%69%32%
Kyle SchwarberPhiladelphia PhilliesPHI1Zac ThorntonLHP22.4%69%38%
Pete AlonsoBaltimore OriolesBAL2Dustin MayRHP22.8%69%41%
Wilyer AbreuBoston Red SoxBOS4Ian SeymourLHP23.7%69%35%
Chase MeidrothChicago White SoxCWS5Andrew SearsLHP24.2%69%32%
Miguel VargasChicago White SoxCWS1Andrew SearsLHP22.4%69%36%
Chase DeLauterCleveland GuardiansCLE3Mason BarnettRHP23.1%69%35%
Konnor GriffinPittsburgh PiratesPIT1Randy DobnakRHP22.3%68%33%
★

Milestone Watch

Players closing in on a season or career mark. Anyone playing tonight is flagged first; lineups post a few hours before first pitch.

Reached since the last card: Jeremy Peña 20 HR · Yordan Alvarez 40 HR · Austin Warren 100th career strikeout

PlayerTeamMilestoneHasNeedsNeed
TONIGHT Bryan ReynoldsPITPIT150 hits1491
TONIGHT José RamírezCLECLE1,000th career RBI9982
TONIGHT Eugenio SuárezCINCIN350th career home run3491
TONIGHT Bryce HarperPHIPHI150 hits1482
TONIGHT Matt OlsonATLATL150 hits1482
TONIGHT Yandy DíazTBTB175 hits1732
TONIGHT Brayan RocchioCLECLE20 SB191
TONIGHT Brice TurangMILMIL20 HR191
TONIGHT Brice TurangMILMIL20 SB191
TONIGHT Caleb DurbinBOSBOS20 SB191
TONIGHT Matt OlsonATLATL40 HR391
TONIGHT Michael BuschCHCCHC20 HR191
TONIGHT Miguel VargasCWSCWS20 SB191
TONIGHT Oneil CruzPITPIT20 HR191
TONIGHT Salvador PerezKCKC20 HR191
TONIGHT Travis BazzanaCLECLE20 SB191
TONIGHT Trea TurnerPHIPHI20 HR191
TONIGHT Brandon NimmoTEXTEX150 hits1473
TONIGHT Chase MeidrothCWSCWS150 hits1473
TONIGHT Mauricio DubónATLATL150 hits1473
TONIGHT Michael ConfortoCHCCHC1,000th career hit9928
TONIGHT Michael Harris IIATLATL100th career home run982
TONIGHT Miguel VargasCWSCWS100 runs982
TONIGHT Cade CavalliWSHWSH200 K1946 proj 6.5 K
TONIGHT William ContrerasMILMIL150 hits1464
TONIGHT Jo AdellCLECLE100th career home run973
TONIGHT Trea TurnerPHIPHI100 runs973
TONIGHT Brice TurangMILMIL150 hits1455
TONIGHT Trea TurnerPHIPHI150 hits1455
TONIGHT Bobby Witt Jr.KCKC20 HR182
TONIGHT Bryce HarperPHIPHI30 HR282
TONIGHT Corey SeagerTEXTEX20 HR182
TONIGHT Dansby SwansonCHCCHC20 HR182
TONIGHT Elly De La CruzCINCIN30 HR282
TONIGHT Hunter GoodmanCOLCOL40 HR382
TONIGHT Jordan WalkerSTLSTL30 HR282
TONIGHT Matt McLainCINCIN20 SB182
TONIGHT Ronald Acuña Jr.ATLATL20 HR182
TONIGHT Ryan O'HearnPITPIT20 HR182
TONIGHT Samuel BasalloBALBAL20 HR182
TONIGHT Zack GelofATHATH20 HR182
TONIGHT Bobby Witt Jr.KCKC150 hits1446
TONIGHT Brandon LowePITPIT150 hits1446
TONIGHT Chandler SimpsonTBTB175 hits1696
TONIGHT Pete Crow-ArmstrongCHCCHC40-40 season44 HR / 37 SB3 SB
TONIGHT Wilyer AbreuBOSBOS150 hits1446
TONIGHT Ian HappCHCCHC200th career home run1964
TONIGHT José RamírezCLECLE300th career home run2964
TONIGHT Sean MurphyATLATL100th career home run964
TONIGHT Brice TurangMILMIL100 runs964
TONIGHT Junior CamineroTBTB100 RBI964
TONIGHT Matt OlsonATLATL100 runs964
TONIGHT Drake BaldwinATLATL150 hits1437
TONIGHT Ozzie AlbiesATLATL150 hits1437
TONIGHT Tyler GlasnowLADLAD50th career win473
TONIGHT Austin RileyATLATL20 HR173
TONIGHT Bryan ReynoldsPITPIT20 HR173
TONIGHT Dansby SwansonCHCCHC20 SB173
TONIGHT Ezequiel DuranTEXTEX20 HR173
TONIGHT JJ WetherholtSTLSTL20 HR173
TONIGHT Jackson ChourioMILMIL20 SB173
TONIGHT Kyle SchwarberPHIPHI100 RBI955
TONIGHT Lawrence ButlerATHATH20 HR173
TONIGHT Nathaniel LoweCLECLE20 HR173
TONIGHT Oneil CruzPITPIT30 SB273
TONIGHT Pete AlonsoBALBAL40 HR373
TONIGHT Pete Crow-ArmstrongCHCCHC40 SB373
TONIGHT Pete Crow-ArmstrongCHCCHC175 hits1678
TONIGHT Pete Crow-ArmstrongCHCCHC120 runs1155
TONIGHT William ContrerasMILMIL20 HR173
TONIGHT Wyatt LangfordTEXTEX20 HR173
Manny MachadoSDSD400th career home run3973
Zack WheelerPHIPHI2,000th career strikeout1,9973
Kenley JansenDETDET500th career save4964
Francisco LindorNYMNYM300th career home run2991
Blake SnellLADLAD1,500th career strikeout1,4928
Carlos RodónNYYNYY1,500th career strikeout1,4928
CJ AbramsWSHWSH30-30 season30 HR / 29 SB1 SB
Jesús LuzardoPHIPHI1,000th career strikeout9964
Steven MatzTBTB1,000th career strikeout9964
Kris BubicLADLAD500th career strikeout4973
Christian WalkerHOUHOU200th career home run1991
Rhys HoskinsCLECLE200th career home run1991
Willson ContrerasBOSBOS200th career home run1991
Carlos EstévezKCKC500th career strikeout4946
Carlos RodónNYYNYY100th career win991
JP SearsSDSD500th career strikeout4919
Mookie BettsLADLAD200th career stolen base1982
Gregory SotoPITPIT500th career strikeout48416
Yoshinobu YamamotoLADLAD500th career strikeout48416
Cole WinnTEXTEX100th career strikeout982
+

Extra Plays

The best outs and earned-run numbers on the board, same engine as the strikeout model. These sit outside the two-pick card above — they are newer markets for us, and we keep the opponent adjustment small on purpose, because this season's team splits are still mostly random.

Connor Prielipp OVER 14.5 outs
vs Los Angeles Angels · 15.8 base × 1.001 matchup → 15.4
65%fair odds -189
Peter Lambert OVER 15.5 outs
vs Atlanta Braves · 16.6 base × 0.996 matchup → 16.3
63%fair odds -170
Ranger Suarez OVER 15.5 outs
vs Tampa Bay Rays · 16.5 base × 1.016 matchup → 16.3
59%fair odds -146
Randy Dobnak UNDER 2.5 ER
vs Pittsburgh Pirates · we project 2.01 earned runs
68%fair odds -212
Ranger Suarez UNDER 2.5 ER
vs Tampa Bay Rays · we project 2.02 earned runs
68%fair odds -210
Clay Holmes UNDER 2.5 ER
vs Cincinnati Reds · we project 2.04 earned runs
67%fair odds -206
W-L

Track Record

Every pick we post gets graded the next day against the box score — wins, losses and all — see every one →

All picks 130-81 (62%)  ·  parlay 3-13  ·  -9.07 units at $100 a card

Newest first. Past results do not predict future outcomes.

Every past card (17)
Our own projections · odds shown are fair value with no house cut — not sportsbook prices
Analysis only · not gambling advice · 21+
@PropsEdgeBTN · Track record · Calculators · NFL · Blog · Learn · How it works · Archive · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · If gambling is a problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER